OlehGirl.com
Bravery that leaves you breathless
Everyone has heard of the brave and heroic act of the nanny, Sandra Samuel, who saved 2 year old Moshe Holtzberg from the horrors that were unfolding at the hands of the terrorists in the Chabad House in Mumbai. But what she truly did in order to save this child is only just now becoming known and the bravery it took simply leaves me breathless.
Sandra Samuel was on the ground floor when the terrorists burst into the four-story building. She locked and barricaded herself into a room on that floor and hunkered down in terror for 12 hours as the gunmen ranged throughout the building, shooting immediately several of the hostages on the floors above, shooting from the windows and killing pedestrians on the street, killing and injuring people in apartments in buildings next door, killing a tailor in his shop down the street. Hours later they killed more of the hostages. And then there was a long lull in the shootings and noise. In that lull, she heard the baby crying.
When I first heard that she had “scooped up the baby and fled” I assumed that the baby was perhaps in the hallway outside her door or in a room across from where she was hiding. Had that been the case, her selfless act would have still been brave and heroic beyond measure. Many people in such situations of incredible fear for their own life think only of saving themselves, not because they are selfish or bad people but rather they are simply unable to cope because they are so overwhelmed with fear and panic. But the fact of the matter was that the baby was not in the hallway nor in a room nearby on that ground floor by the exit.
The baby was upstairs. The baby was upstairs where the terrorists were. The terrorists had gone up to the roof of the building but Sandra Samuel did not know that when she left her barricaded room and, rather than fleeing out the door to save her own life, crept up those stairs to where she could hear the baby’s cries. She did not know where the terrorists were when she went up into the killing grounds to try to save that little boy. At some point during those first 12 hours of siege, little Moshe has climbed out of his crib and his nanny found him sitting and crying, covered in blood, among the bodies of the victims. It was from this place that she scooped him and fled back downstairs and then out the door toward safety.
I will tell you that, untested, I’d like to believe that I too would climb up into the lion’s den to save a child –my own or someone else’s — but I don’t know if I would have that kind of strength, that level of bravery and heroism. I don’t know if, standing so close to freedom and in such fear for my own life, that I would be able to make myself climb those stairs up to where I would have a very good chance of coming face to face with a maniac with a gun who would be more than happy to slaughter me on sight. I keep picturing this woman, standing there at the bottom of the stairs like a classic scene from a horror movie where everyone in the audience is screaming, “no, don’t go up, are you stupid?!” –and still going up.
That, my friends, is not stupidity but the face of true heroism that simply takes my breath away.
| Print article | This entry was posted by Yael on December 1, 2008 at 6:35 pm, and is filed under Israel. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
(Photo by Dani Machlis)


about 1 year ago
i think, that if you ask anyone who is a parent if the scenario you wrote is beyond the realm of possibility and the answer would be absolutely not. parents are not kidding when they say they would die for their children… not to say that a parent putting themselves in danger for their child is anything less than heroic, but what is amazing here is the depth of feeling sandra has for moshe being that she is not his parent, but a caregiver who has an obvious attachment to him beyond this being simply her job.
about 1 year ago
the various online israeli news sites have been reporting on the impending arrival of sandra samuels…. saying that she will assist in moshe tzvi holtzberg’s transition to life in israel and with his grandparents….
i hope that in sharing her obvious capacity for love and comfort with moshe tzvi and his family, that ms. samuels will find a measure of peace and a way to mend her heart and soul after the horrors she endured. i simply can not imagine how one begins to heal after such an ordeal.
ms. samuel’s bravery and selflessness has left us all breathless — thank you for articulating what many of us feel, but have trouble expressing!
about 1 year ago
She did in fact have a fellow employee with her when she was hiding who tried to dissuade her from going to save Moishe.
See:
http://blog.z-word.com/2008/11/mumbai-sandra-samuels-heroism/
As you say, bravery beyond belief.
about 1 year ago
yer damn right.
about 1 year ago
For the last couple of years we have had an inflation in the use of the word hero. This story shows us someone who truly deserves to be called a hero.
about 1 year ago
Yes, she is a true heroine.
about 1 year ago
It’s more braver than you first realize, on account of the baby was CRYING, and for her to take a baby that was making noise and could lead to her getting discovered by the terrorists tracking down the crying, is just unbelievable!!! But it’s strange, this story is not really being played up much in the USA media, I guess in part because the more gruesome and crime-filled stories are the favored chow of editors and readers alike.
But what is starting to show up in the media is some stories about Israel “not waiting” on USA approval before jumping on Iran nuke stuff. I’m torn on this, and I would like to hear what peson Yael says about it, if she gets around to writing about it. Because if Israel goes in, then you know we have to back them no matter what. But that is just going to make the whole area go up in flames, maybe. I don’t know. I need the professor to weigh in on it. I think these stories aren’t out of concern for repercussions, but attempts to get people real mad at Israel before the holidays. Israel isn’t perfect and can get me steamed, but I just sense these “attack Iran w/no permission” stories are hate-based some kind of way.
Also more cat update posts are needed, thanks.
about 1 year ago
I think that the fear that many countries have (and not just Israel) is that if Iran gets nuclear weapons it will be too late to do much about this aggressive and unpredictable country that hates not only Israel, but also the UK and the US. They have vowed to destroy Israel, said so many times, so to wait for them to get the means to do it does seem stupid.
about 1 year ago
I know a lot of good Persians. Radicals got ahold of their country, and it was, frankly, U.S.A. mischief that allowed it to happen, because we went in there and protected the Shah, but there is always more than one reason why we did so, so I can’t attack what we did, really, and the Shah was not a radical Muslim-type, and at that point, Iran was at least secular in nature with room for all. But then, the extremists got ahold of it. Persia was a great, great country. It reminds me of in Lord of the Rings, when Frodo said to the other hobbits who wanted to strike down old Saruman, “No, he has fallen, but once he was great, and of a noble race we would never dare lift our hands against” (not exact quote) and so I feel this about Iran, truly, they were noble and many still are, but laying low due to the extremists. What is a lesson to all nations is how quick, without a democracy or a republic, and a strong consitution, this can happen!!!!!!
about 1 year ago
Reader, I agree. I like and admire the Iranian people that I know. And, yes, the US protected the Shah and created a terrible situation for the Persians.